Peacock’s dark comedy-thriller Based on a True Story, led by Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina, delivered two gripping seasons before it met an unexpected end. Despite fan enthusiasm and a cliffhanger begging for more, the series was canceled—and that’s the story moving forward.
Current Status of Season 3
The hiatus of hope has ended: as of April 2025, Peacock officially canceled Based on a True Story after two seasons, putting any plans for Season 3 to rest. The announcement was made roughly five months after the release of Season 2, which dropped in November 2024 (tvline.com). Although executive producer Michael Costigan had earlier expressed optimism—“if the audience is there with us in Season 2, we really think and hope that they’re going to want to go with us again” (yahoo.com)—Peacock ultimately chose not to continue.
Fans expressed disappointment across social media. Some even threatened to cancel their Peacock subscriptions, lamenting unresolved cliffhangers and praising a show that held solid approval ratings (around 79–83%) on Rotten Tomatoes (the-sun.com). Despite critical acclaim and unresolved narrative threads, the streamer did not provide viewership numbers or reasoning behind the decision (decider.com).
Cast, Characters & Creative Team
Main Cast & Roles
- Kaley Cuoco stars as Ava Bartlett, a pregnant real estate agent with a growing obsession for true crime (tvline.com).
- Chris Messina plays Nathan Bartlett, her husband and former tennis pro turned coach (tvline.com).
- Tom Bateman portrays Matt Pierce, the serial killer-turned-podcast-co-host who becomes entwined with the couple in unexpected ways (tvline.com).
- Sara Paxton joins in Season 2 as Paige, the copycat killer revealed in dramatic fashion—and even she expressed desire to return for a third season (people.com).
- Supporting faces include Priscilla Quintana, Liana Liberato, and Natalia Dyer, each adding depth to the twisted world of true-crime podcasts gone wrong (cbr.com).
Behind the Scenes
- The series was created by Craig Rosenberg, with executive production by Rosenberg, Jason Bateman, Michael Costigan, Kaley Cuoco, Annie Weisman, and others (en.wikipedia.org).
- Annie Weisman took over showrunner duties in Season 2 and openly felt there was more story to tell—“the potential of either [Matt and Paige] teaming up, or a fight to the death between them. … They’re definitely not done yet.” (tvline.com).
Plot Recap & Narrative Threads Left Unresolved
Season 1 Highlights
Ava and Nathan latch onto America’s obsession with true crime by launching a podcast featuring convicted serial killer Matt. What starts as a cynical ploy ramps up into a twisted relationship web—Ava’s sister Tory even gets romantically involved with Matt (tvline.com).
Season 2 Twists
The couple grapples with motherhood alongside true-crime fame. Enter Paige, a copycat killer driven by personal vendetta. She captures Ava and Nathan in their studio, threatening them with death—only for Matt to unexpectedly intervene. The season ends explosively: Matt flees with Paige, and Nathan is detained, suspected of being the Westside Ripper (tvline.com).
Cliffhanger Conundrum
The show ended on a high-tension note: unresolved relationships, unresolved mysteries, and survival hanging by a thread. Despite creatives hinting at further battles between Matt and Paige, season 3 will never come—or so it seems (tvline.com).
Streaming & Viewing Details
- Based on a True Story premiered on June 8, 2023 (en.wikipedia.org).
- Season 2 followed on November 21, 2024, consisting of eight episodes (en.wikipedia.org).
- The full two-season run (16 episodes) remains available to stream exclusively on Peacock (cbr.com).
- There’s no word yet on a final wrap-up special or a revival—fans remain hopeful for closure elsewhere (reddit.com).
“They’re definitely not done yet.”
— Showrunner Annie Weisman, reflecting on untold possibilities for Matt and Paige’s arc (tvline.com)
What This Means for Fans & the Industry
Peacock’s decision underscores the unpredictable nature of streaming programming—even series with solid reviews and strong fan engagement aren’t immune to sudden cancellation. Industry insiders note streaming platforms often favor new content over closure, leaving ambitious narratives hanging (decider.com).
Despite disappointment, Based on a True Story still stands as a smart, self-aware satire about society’s fascination with criminal infamy. Its layered characters, dark humor, and social commentary retain value—and perhaps hope remains for revival in another form, even if only in fan petitions or limited specials.
Conclusion
In short:
- Based on a True Story ran two seasons (June 2023 – November 2024) on Peacock before being canceled in April 2025 (en.wikipedia.org).
- The cast includes Kaley Cuoco, Chris Messina, Tom Bateman, Sara Paxton, among others, with a creative team led by Rosenberg and Weisman (people.com).
- Season 2 left major plotlines unresolved—a narrative no-show for Season 3 leaves the story hanging (tvline.com).
- All episodes remain streamable now on Peacock (en.wikipedia.org).
- Though the door to Season 3 is closed, the show’s satirical edge and cultural critique continue to resonate—and fans hope for some creative closure someday.
For now, avid viewers can relive the twisted journey of Ava, Nathan, Matt, and Paige—each lingering moment now cemented in a series abruptly halted yet hauntingly potent.
Feature image suggestion: A stylized, moody still of Kaley Cuoco and Tom Bateman facing off, encapsulating the tension, drama, and dark satire that defined the series.
Leave a comment